Palworld developer Pocket Pair has released an update for the creature-catching survival game removing the ability to s…
@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
1521M

Lame. Thanks, Nintendo. Got forbid you actually try to outcompete.

“Don’t innovate, litigate!”

-Nintendo

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
0
edit-2
1M

“Don’t care, just buy”

- Gamers

Anti Commercial-AI license

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
511M

It’s a shame the Wii U didn’t bankrupt Nintendo.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
81M

I do wonder if the steam deck exists in this alternate timeline you propose

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
91M

It probably does with detachable controllers.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
51M

No, but we do have a proper Nvidia Shield Portable 2.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
181M

Nintendo could afford to release 10 failed consoles in a row and still keep going, that was the case back when the Wii U released as well

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
11M

This constantly gets repeated, but I’ve yet to see proof of it.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
11M

They’re publically traded, their finances are public, the Wii and Switch secured the company for decades

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
21M

as of March 2024 Nintendo has $14.87 Billion in cash on hand.

in comparison in March of 2024 Apple had $162 Billion.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
4
edit-2
1M

Proof of what? Nintendo having a shit-ton of money? I don’t understand why you would even need a source of that, but sure, here’s one

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
21M

A shame they didn’t

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
11M

We got Tears of the Kingdom, but at what cost?

JackbyDev
link
fedilink
English
41M

Poor frame rate

Lvxferre
cake
link
fedilink
English
91M

If Palworld devs were as petty as I am they’d probably make a Pal that looks like an obese and hostile Pikachu with a Mario hat.

  • Name: Renjiyu / レンヂユ; after a really shitty Mandarin joke with Nintendo’s name (basically calling it hell’s company).
  • It would make a noise that sounds a lot like uttaeru / 訴える “to sue, to complain” with an incredibly whiny voice
  • Drop: meat and sulphur (the in-game sulphur looks a lot like fool’s gold)
  • “Utility”: when it’s running around your base, Renjiyu makes your pals drop whatever they are doing to listen to its ramblings. As in, negative utility.

Bonus points if the logo in the hat resembles a pokeball from a distance.

Venia Silente
link
fedilink
English
123d

This sounds awesome; requesting permission to use it if Palworld doesn’t? It’s for a book.

Lvxferre
cake
link
fedilink
English
223d

requesting permission to use it if Palworld doesn’t? It’s for a book.

You’re welcome to use this idea for whatever reason you want, mate.

Venia Silente
link
fedilink
English
223d

Yay! Thanks.

FreshLight
link
fedilink
English
63
edit-2
1M

What a sad sad outcome. Patenting game mechanics should not be legal.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
121M

It isn’t in the US but is in Japan where the companies are based.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
91M

It’s still somewhat protected in the US. The big one in table top gaming was tap mechanics from Magic. That expired in 2014 though. In video games the Nemesis system from Shadow of Mordor/war is also patented.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
61M

Loading screen mini games are also patented. That’s why loading screens never have mini games. Less of an issue now that game devs have begun avoiding loading screens, but they were extremely common in older generations and they never had mini games to pass the time.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
11M

I remember how impressive that was as a kid, when i played ridge racer on psx the first time.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
71M

Erm, acktchually! I think Nintendo is pretty cringe here, not based!

(Sorry, I couldn’t resist)

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
21M

Take this vote and leave before I change my mind

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
61M

Ok, I’m outta here.

All jokes aside, I would like to weigh in and say that I find the whole patenting of game mechanics to be absolutely appalling. I genuinely don’t get how this is legal, even in Japan. They filed this patent way too late for it to even make sense.

You could’ve made an argument if they patented it back in 1996, but even so… Fuck this. Imagine patenting a screen transition or something?

Uninvited Guest
link
fedilink
English
111M

*Patenting

FreshLight
link
fedilink
English
21M

Oh, thanks. Corrected it

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
1051M

These primarily cover throwing an object in a specific direction to either summon a battle character or to capture a creature in the field - mechanics Palworld shared with Pokémon at launch.

sounds like a mechanic found in a number of video games.

JackbyDev
link
fedilink
English
13
edit-2
1M

That’s the weird thing. It doesn’t seem to matter. The patent was filed after PalWorld was released. I’m guessing this is some quirk of Japan’s patent system I’m unfamiliar with.

That’s because it is, Pokemon didn’t come up with it, they just made it popular.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
161M

Like what? I can’t think of one off the top of my head.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
221M

Bulma keeps machinery in tiny capsules

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
211M

They should go after Rockstar for the mechanic of throwing a rope at an animal to catch it, if this is the criteria. Ridiculous.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
141M

Ratchet and Clank’s glove of doom fits the bill

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
181M

The VG made by pocketpair before the patent was issued for one.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
531M

in minecraft you throw eggs to hatch chickens

ghostbusters, throwing trap to catch ghosts

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
141M

Summoning a dedra in skyrim?

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
61M

You don’t throw an object for that, you cast a spell, and I don’t remember being able to target it, but then I never really used those spells.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
31M

It is a spell but iirc the animation is a little ball that goes where you point it.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
551M

You could argue against anything involving throwing a net to capture something, like monster hunter for the small fauna. Ark has “cryo pods” that function basically like pokeballs.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
71M

Does Ghostbusters count?

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
51M

Helldivers has this, I believe. if a teammate dies then you have to throw an object to summon down a drop pod at a specific location

Uh, nets IRL for starters, but there are shitloads of games with capture and summon mechanics ranging from Ghost Busters to ARK to Ratchet and Clank to fucking Skyrim.

Edit: Downvote all you want, but don’t ask the question if you don’t want the answer.

Bilb!
link
fedilink
English
-11M

Interesting, every example people have given you in response is pretty weak. (I’m not saying I agree with Nintendo have any exclusive claim here.)

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
531M

Make it so you launch the ball thing from a sling shot, that’s not throwing the object and it fits the universe

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
201M

This is the answer right here. There’s even a few late game items for this. The just need to readjust the costs for those launchers. Make them available early mid game.

JackbyDev
link
fedilink
English
101M

Literally just change the throw animation to use a weaker looking slingshot than whatever the current weakest one is.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
11M

The current weakest one is a bazooka.

JackbyDev
link
fedilink
English
11M

Awesome, should be easy enough to make a little hand sling shot your character pulls out of a pocket.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
9
edit-2
1M

This game is still in early access so I hope this is only temporary and they will retool this to not be similar to Pokemon. There’s no way this will be final right…?? No summon animation at all??!

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
251M

make it so you shoot them out with a gun

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
51M

You already do that eventually anyway.

So fucking stupid. I remember a time when Nintendo was constantly losing legal battles like this one.

Uninvited Guest
link
fedilink
English
41M

How do Japanese patents differ from USA/CAN? My general understanding of patents is that they expire after 20 years - Pokemon is older than that. Do Japanese patents have a longer duration? Did Nintendo patent a game later than the originals?

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
81M

These patents were granted to Nintendo this year.

Uninvited Guest
link
fedilink
English
21M

I’m not patent savvy - of they are only granted this year (as a point of origin for the patents’ eventually expiry), wouldn’t the years of previous Pokemon games invalidate these patents due to prior art?

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
11M

If they were related to the original games, yes it would. The patents were about 3d worlds though. I believe the palworld beta was before these patents were filed, so there would be a strong case to invalidate them. It probably won’t happen, because Nintendo’s proposed damages was basically pocket change compared to a legal battle.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
21M

You wouldn’t patent the “game” you’d patent the various forms of utility or designs within that game. So throwing a sphere at a life form to then capture it could be one patent, but maybe then you’d also file another patent to cover keeping it alive and caring for it inside the ball habitat. You might file the second off of what is called a continuation filling and in combination, as you need both actions to get the full effect, you might get a bit of extended coverage in practice.

But the bigger thing here would probably be trademark law, which is a whole different beast.

Uninvited Guest
link
fedilink
English
11M

Sure, I hadn’t implied that the game was patented, but the mechanics were present in a game that is over 30 years old.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
21M

Worried what this means for Nexomon 3

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
-65
edit-2
1M

I am not usually in favour of big companies bullying smaller companies with the law, but it’s pretty egregious how much they were ripping off Pokémon.

Edited to add, apparently this was a really hot take. I am not saying that the gameplay between the games was similar, but I saw a comparison of several of the designs of the creatures for the first time when this whole kinda started kicking off a bit ago and it was the first time I realized how blatant the designs were lifted right from popular Pokémon. Combined specifically with the pokeball-alikes and like… I don’t know how people can defend it. There’s homage and then there’s IP theft.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
381M

The game itself isn’t ripping off anything. Pokémon is such a direct “rip off” of digimon, too, then. Except it doesn’t matter, cause that’s what stuff is. Stuff is made up of other stuff and oftentimes there will be similarities!

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
71M

I mean, for one I was talking about the designs of the creatures and the specific ball mechanic/theme, but also Pokémon came out before Digimon anyway.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
111M

Gen 1 Pokemon designs were straight rips of Dragon Quest monsters.

Arguably the Poke ball mechanic first appeared in anime such as Dragon Ball, Im not sure on any games predating Pokemon, but if they had patented it with the first games release it would have expired by now.

Nintendo will pull off some bullshit but they really shouldn’t have a leg to stand on.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
1
edit-2
1M

How was Dragon Ball similar to pokeballs and their catching mechanics? I’m not seeing that similarity at all.

Never seen any comparisons between Dragon Quest and Pokémon. Do you have examples?

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
131M

The anime one will be harder to source clips but I do recall creatures being released as ‘energy’ then forming quickly from thrown objects. Will need to get back to you on that one!

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
11M

Don’t really agree with the top pic at all, but some of the comparisons in the bottom one are interesting. Some are slay a really big stretch I think, but I do see why people would compare. I think if Enix went after Nintendo in the early nineties I could get behind them on a couple of these, but that ship has sailed a long time ago.

Still going to disagree about the Dragon Ball comparison. Not really seeing any comparison between those two.

JackbyDev
link
fedilink
English
21M

They might be referring to CapsuleCorp’s capsules. They would store big things in tiny capsules, much like Poke balls work. I don’t recall people or monsters ever being store in them, nor do I remember things forcibly being put into them at all. It’s possible this was bigger on Dragon Ball, as a kid I was more familiar with Dragon Ball Z.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
11M

Lemmy is the wrong place to mention Nintendo. You will get obliterated by people.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
-61M

I don’t mind. It’s no different than Reddit, people see downvotes and just pile on. No room for discussion, no thoughtful discourse, just hive mind.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
21M

I don’t remember the vitriol being as consistent on reddit. On a larger scale here, if it’s a computer, it needs to be Linux or you’re downvoted. If it’s video games, it needs to be a PC or they don’t want to hear about it. Even Steam that was generally loved on Reddit gets some flack, because GOG is more DRM free from what I can tell (I don’t game on PCs)

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
51M

Brother, you made a stupid comment. You didn’t read the article and you don’t know why the lawsuit is happening. Literally all of your comments are irrelevant to the discussion — you can’t hide behind it’s the hivemind!

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
-3
edit-2
1M

I did read the article and I do know why the lawsuit is happening, at least what’s been reported, as I’ve read a few articles about it. I’m not hiding behind anything, and people are free to disagree with me.

A reminder that all I said at first was that I was surprised to find out just how much they were ripping off Pokémon, and what I was referring to (but not clearly) were in many of the designs and the brazen pokeballs. I didn’t comment on the lawsuit at all, at first.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
4
edit-2
1M

I really hope you’re lying because if you do know what this is about, then that just makes all of your comments worse. Also, you’re calling people who disagree with you a hivemind, so don’t try to pretend you’re fine with it.

You said that, in this case, you were in favor of a big company bullying a little one with the law because they ripped off pokemon designs, which isn’t even a topic that is being discussed here. If anyone needs a reminder of what you commented, it’s you.

JackbyDev
link
fedilink
English
121M

I’d be more willing to agree if Nintendo was going after them for similar art styles. They went after them for fucking throwing balls of all things. This is going to set a horrible precedent for the game industry.

So either Nintendo didn’t believe the monster designs were rip offs, or they didn’t feel it was a proper violation because they’ve shown themselves as willing to litigate.

@[email protected]
mod
link
fedilink
English
161M

You mean like Pokémon “ripping off” Dragon Quest?

You can’t patent an art style.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
11M

For one, I didn’t say you could patent an art style. But distinguishable character can be IP. You’re like the fifth person to mention Dragon Quest and I’ve never heard of that comparison before, do you have any examples?

@[email protected]
mod
link
fedilink
English
41M

There are a bunch of images out there making the comparison, but here’s a good video of just a direct side to side of each design. https://youtu.be/CZXKKbSCA34

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
191M

Pokemon is a rip off of Dragon Quest and Shin Megami Tensei.

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
31M

They’re both based on the same source material - various mythological creatures and real animals with a twist

I used to think Pokemon was super original - but a lot of it just seems they way because we don’t learn much about Japanese or asian folklore overseas.

Like take Magikarp. There’s a Chinese proverb about a carp leaping through the dragons gate (an actual waterfall) turning into a dragon (meant to describe how with diligence a common person could become powerful through the civil official exams)… The weak magic carp, if diligently leveled, can become a Chinese dragon that looks exactly like the ones they use in parades.

Meouth - a wealth giving cat, many asian shops have a cat figure with a gold coin for luck. And Persian is just a lioness (a bigger cat) with the same design.

Vulpix/Ninetails - nine tailed fox

Ekans - snakE. Arbok - kobrA. Pidgey - pigeon. Pigiotto, pigeot? Reminds me of fire, fira, firaga, firaja naming scheme from final fantasy

Hitmonlee and Hitmonchan - Bruce Lee and Jackie Chan

Noticably, most of these puns and references to actual people are not copied, instead it is things like wolves and mythological creatures

If anything, it’s the style of the art that makes them so similar - but copying aesthetics is how art grows and develops. It’s not like they were the first or only ones to copy the style either

Noxy
link
fedilink
English
51M

I disagree with your premise but even if I agreed that any IP theft has occurred, why do you care? surely you’re aware that nintendo aggressively invests in IP lawyers and lawsuits?

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
-41M

Well, yes, that’s why the lawsuit was happening. I’m not sure what your point was. I care because I think that IP theft is wrong.

Noxy
link
fedilink
English
51M

that’s actually not why the lawsuit is happening though…

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
51M

The lawsuite is Happening because of patent trolling…

@[email protected]
link
fedilink
English
41M

How’s that billionaire cock feel against your throat?

Create a post

For PC gaming news and discussion. PCGamingWiki

Rules:

  1. Be Respectful.
  2. No Spam or Porn.
  3. No Advertising.
  4. No Memes.
  5. No Tech Support.
  6. No questions about buying/building computers.
  7. No game suggestions, friend requests, surveys, or begging.
  8. No Let’s Plays, streams, highlight reels/montages, random videos or shorts.
  9. No off-topic posts/comments, within reason.
  10. Use the original source, no clickbait titles, no duplicates. (Submissions should be from the original source if possible, unless from paywalled or non-english sources. If the title is clickbait or lacks context you may lightly edit the title.)
  • 1 user online
  • 124 users / day
  • 324 users / week
  • 889 users / month
  • 3.15K users / 6 months
  • 1 subscriber
  • 4.48K Posts
  • 28.8K Comments
  • Modlog