I think everyone will be fine with a slightly improved GTA V set in Florida / Miama. One of the protagonists is also a thirst trap latina and the gameplay mechanics in the leak seemed nice. Like with read dead but improved.
The reward should not be at the cost of degradation of player experience of other players who do not pay. If you can do that, sure. Like cosmetic dice dlc for instance.
How did you conclude that? How else are they supposed to not make 193 million in losses?