
Writing quality and general theme. Among those four titles, you’ve got zombie apocalypse, space western, Batman, and an urban fantasy retelling of fairy tales. Taking Borderlands for example, if nothing about the Borderlands franchise interests a player, it’s unlikely the Telltale one will either. It’s not impossible, but I wouldn’t put money on the odds.

Right. I’m going to have to suggest you re-read my comment and the context. What I was saying was that a ghost function that isn’t AI-powered wouldn’t be susceptible to legal action under this patent. I also have no doubt Sony will force this in anyway. All of the big companies have gone gaga for AI. I have absolutely no idea why other than very poorly made projections, but the reality is they insist on using the biggest crowbar they can find.

I don’t disagree with the 30% being too much. That said, Steam often provides more than just a sales pages for the fee, they always provide server access for multiplayer and cloud saving. That has to get covered somehow. I also believe in celebrating the good things going and there really aren’t many of those in the gaming market these days, certainly not in the AAA-money tier. I’m going to enjoy the wins we get. If you don’t want to do that, enjoy being miserable, I guess.

Till it goes public or his son decides to shit all over it for profit.
This risks being true for any and every successful company and is a genuine concern, but this is why I only named Gabe in my comment. Being a private company and him as CEO, based on statements from him in the past, pro-consumer practices are his directive. What-aboutisms have nothing to do with it.

Agreed. I think the examples you named would lead to there being an insane amount of categories, not to mention the ludicrous amount of games that would fall under a category like “roguelike of the year” and some categories wouldn’t be present some years based on design trends. Categories absolutely need reform though. The way TGA currently does it is obnoxiously flawed.

I’m neither simping for Gabe nor am I glazing anything I like. In fact, I often don’t like Steam, the client, at least. Why I say Gabe is because he (or his staff) commonly make consumer-friendly decisions for the platform. Check out a YT channel called Bellular News and search Steam. It’s full of good-news pieces of things Gabe or Steam have done in the last year alone. Compared to all of the bad-news pieces always being about pretty much every other company, hearing about Steam is a breath of fresh air.

I’d back that. Possibly GOTY and genre GOTY, but then none of the “Best Soundtrack”, “Best Gameplay” and such. I think if a game is winning the top prize, it’s already pretty obvious it’s doing many of the aspect categories well too, so give some of the Spotlight to games that really shine in that particular aspect.
A friend of mine keeps making the argument of “What, we need to say ‘you’re winning too much’ and give pity prizes to the others? If it’s the best, it’s the best.” and I think that’s typically fine until we have years where games like Baldur’s Gate 3 and Expedition 33 come out and make the award ceremony boring and not giving other games awards they deserve. My example this year is Dispatch and the difference between TGA and the Steam Awards. Dispatch is my personal GOTY, I love it, but I can easily say the gameplay was meh. Why I love it is the fact it absolutely nailed comic book superhero stories up-to-and-including the delayed gratification of the waiting period to think and theorise before the next piece comes out so, for a Story award category, I don’t think anything beats it.
Part of the challenge is not that many people played Dispatch compared to E33 so giving a much smaller competitor the award, I think, would be a great way of pointing the spotlight on an amazing work of art and possibly get more people to give it a go, possibly coming to a similar opinion on their own. Filtering out the crap and helping us players focus our time on the worthwhile games is already part of what we expect from gaming journalists, so why not a prestige event too?
Edit: Didn’t realise how much I rambled on for before hitting post so TL;DR: Individualising awards = Yay

Then it’s a good thing you don’t have to play it if the game ever comes out, huh? And believe it or not but you also don’t need to be an asshole about other people enjoying something. There are a lot of objective downsides to AI, but an IP you don’t like is just something for you to ignore. The horror.
I’m glad to say I’ve never had dealings with Intuit by that measure then.